Twisted String Actuators: Surprisingly Simple, Cheap, and High Gear Ratio

Twisted String Actuator

A few years back I learned about an actuator that is surprisingly simple, has a high gear ratio, was known since ancient times, and can be produced with nothing more than a cheap hobby motor and some string. Crazy, right?! Up until recently I was barred from discussing the actuator due to NDAs with an anonymous startup, despite plenty of academic work on the subject. Thankfully those NDAs expired, and I've received permission to discuss some of that company's findings publicly.  Read on for details!

 

 

Twisted String Actuator Concept

 

The concept is surprisingly simple: hook up two wires to a motor on one side and a load on the other; twist the wires, which causes their effective length to shrink and linearly pull the load:

Twisted String actuator concept

 

The actuator is so simple; it appears in several kids' project books (eg. "Ink Sandwiches, Electric Worms, and 37 Other Experiments for Saturday Science" and "Vacuum Bazookas, Electric Rainbow Jelly"), where they're used to build rudimentary robots.  This is Arduino territory right here:

Twisted String Actuator for Children's toy Twisted String Actuator for Children's "Worm" robot

The worm comprises a set of identical pad-motor units that slide on the ground and are linked by arched wires (springs) that push the units apart and by twisted-string actuators that pull the units together.

 

And the basic concept has been known since ancient times:

Ancient versions of twisted string actuators Ancient versions of twisted string actuators Ancient versions of twisted string actuators

Ancient versions of twisted string actuators

Ancient versions of twisted string actuators

 

 

Twisted String Actuators in Academia:

 

The actuator's simplicity masks some interesting physics. Hod Lipson (etal.) wrote one of the better papers, entitled "Mini Twist: A Study of Long-Range Linear Drive by String Twisting" (PDF). This paper looks at theoretical models as well as empirical data regarding displacement, tension, force, etc for a variety of string configurations (number strands, materials, etc):

Twisted String actuator from Hod Lipson's group

Twisted String actuator from Hod Lipson's group

 

Meanwhile, Dexmart (various sources: 123, 4, 5) is probably the most-experienced of the academic labs at building and employing the actuators in real robotic systems.  For example, this small actuator is able to lift 7 kilograms, despite being powered by a 12.4mm diameter motor (aka, a pager motor).

 Twisted String actuator from Dexmart  Twisted String actuator from Dexmart  Twisted String actuator from Dexmart

 

Dexmart has also used these actuators to build tendon-driven robot hands that are somewhat anthropomorphic.

  Twisted String actuator from Dexmart    Twisted String actuator hand from Dexmart Twisted String actuator hand from Dexmart Twisted String actuator hand from Dexmart Twisted String actuator hand from Dexmart Twisted String actuator hand from Dexmart

 

A few other, relatively-obscure papers, like "Twisted Strings-based Elbow Exoskeleton" out of Korea, also discuss the practical considerations for mounting and affixing the strings to pulleys and cams:

Twisted String actuator with separator for driving pulley Twisted String actuator concept

 

Another fun fact: Jorge Cham (of PhD Comics fame) worked on some twisted string actuator fingers at Stanford in the late 1990's:

Jorge Cham's twisted string actuator-based finger Jorge Cham's twisted string actuator-based finger Jorge Cham's twisted string actuator-based finger

 

 

Twisted String Actuators: Caveats

 

So why aren't twisted string actuators taking over the world? The startup I mentioned, which asked to remain anonymous, had this to say (paraphrased):

We spent a fair bit of time evaluating twisted string actuators to build low-cost robots. Unfortunately, they have some major problems that are tough to overcome for our specific application(s). For one, their lifecycle is measured in the many thousands instead of millions -- despite our best efforts at material engineering. For another, they are highly nonlinear in response (twists vs displacement), which requires very precise calibration for precision movements.  Plus, they're inherently linear motors; for rotary motion, you need two opposing motors or spring-return mechanisms.  That said.... there are probably a lot of applications that could benefit from this type of actuator!

 

Indeed, I believe toys are probably the sweet spot for these actuators -- whether eldercare robots like Paro (below left), a toy teddy bear (like the one from the movie AI), or even an inflatable toy Baymax from Disney's Big Hero 6 (this was the idea I alluded to earlier when chatting about inflatable robots).

Robot Seal named Paro robot teddy bear (concept only, not real) Big Hero 6 Inflatable Robo

 

So the final takeaway: These actuators are pretty interesting, especially for a certain class of applications.  Definitely worth adding to your bag of tricks!

 

 

A Different type of "Twisted String" Thermal Actuator

 

In 2014, researchers discovered another type of "twisted string" actuator.... but this one was much different than the one I've discussed here.  It's made of nylon string (fishing line or sewing thread), and is heat-activated.  In many respects, it's like more-traditional shape memory alloys -- including the same drawbacks (thermal actuation, cycle time, etc). But it is exceedingly interesting!

It was published in Nature: "Artificial Muscles from Fishing Line and Sewing Thread."  Actually, there's a RobotsPodcast about this technology too. To quote from some of the press coverage:

"The energy per cycle that we obtain from these artificial muscles, and their weightlifting abilities, are extraordinary," says Baughman. "They can lift about 100 times heavier weight and generate about 100-times higher power than natural muscle of the same weight and length." 

The researchers' artificial muscles can be triggered by a range of stimuli, but the common denominator of activation is heat. 

Fishing String Thermal Actuator 

Fishing String Thermal Actuator

 

 

 

Comments

I wonder if and how nanotube strings could be used for this application, they are considered to be very strong as well. - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_nanotube

—Brian

It looks like I missed one: The BioRobotics Lab from Korea University of Technology and Education seems to be doing a lot of great work on twisted string actuators.  Their work is definitely worth checking out!  Also, their free-body diagram is much better than the one I was using before; it accurately shows the twist in the string.

Twisted String Actuator

—Travis Deyle

Couldn't you make your wire in a loop and run it like a belt on your car fan?

I also would like to know if anyone is selling small working models?

—Bradley Metcalf

Just a smile and the rain is gone Can hardly believe it, yeah. There's an angel standing next to me. Reaching for my heart Just a smile and there's no way back .Can hardly believe it, yeah But there's an angel calling me. Reaching for my heart I know that I'll be okay now. This time, it's real I lay my love on you It's all I wanna do Every time I breathe I feel brand new You open up my heart Show me all your love and walk right through As I lay my love on you. } dumb ways to die } fireboy and watergirl 4

—chelsieanayas

whatsapp plus iphone

This is Very Nice Post Fantastic material and amazing article.I most want to say that you are doing a great job.Thanks for this nice article.

Your article reflects the issue people are concerned about. The article provides timely information that reflects multi-dimensional views from multiple perspectives. I look forward to reading quality articles that contain timely information from you.

 

Thanks for your post! Through your pen I found the problem up interesting! I believe there are many other people who are interested in them just like me! How long does it take to complete this article? I have read through other blogs, but they are cumbersome and confusing. I hope you continue to have such quality articles to share with everyone!

slither io

thanks for shared

master

Thanks for such a great post and the review....

 

Best Sunglasses for Fishing

 

 

Best Halloween Costumes 2017

—free1

This is great websites, I visited some of them but I didn't know that Google offers free games.And this is I play free flash games in this websites. - https://driving-directionsmaps.com/  

 Spider is a type of a patience game it is one of more famous solitaire games to visit it click here and get the link and start to fun http://solitairetimes.com/spider/ the main purpose of this game is to remove all the cards from the table before assembling them in the table so lovely game it is.I just love this one and play everyday.Thanks for the game.

—play spider solitaire

This a good way to appreciate the teacher as they put their efforts to train students. UK dissertation Writers appreciates the teachers. https://admissionessayservice.xyz  

Good way of telling, good post to take facts regarding my presentation subject matter, which i am going to deliver in my college https://admissionessayshelp.xyz

Crack For Games

This is very much a work in progress whenever I find out about one who is more beautiful than any of these I will add her and kick out number ten Thanks for sharing the informative post.

—Anonymous

Thanks for sharing. I see the novelty of your writing, I will share it for everyone to read together. I look forward to reading many articles from you. impossiblegameaz.blogspot.com impossiblegameblog.wordpress.com sites.google.com/site/impossiblegameaz impossiblegameaz.weebly.com

—impossible

I Was Even Looking For This Information And At Last Found This Article..!!  So Much Thankful To You Guys..!!  http://www.celebstyleoutfits.com/batman-begins-christian-bale-biker-jacket

My friend recommended this blog and he was totally right keep up the fantastic work!

 

My friend recommended this blog and he was totally right keep up the fantastic work!

 

My friend recommended this blog and he was totally right keep up the fantastic work!

 

Good way of telling, good post to take facts regarding my presentation subject matter, which i am going to deliver in my college

 

Many good tips i can found here.

Here is a compilation of some of the best Wedding Anniversary Wishes For You. Weddings are union of two people whose souls are already united on heaven by God. So it is very special occasion for both bride and groom. To make it more special for them their friends and family members do a lot of things for them like giving surprise parties, gifts, cakes, greetings etc. You can also send them happy wedding anniversary wishes to the most lovely couples. Happy wedding anniversary greetings can be used as well. On every wedding anniversary of the couple their love, care and respect for each other increases and it is very special day for them, so you can add to their happiness by sending some good thoughts and words of pleasure for the couple. If you cannot think of some message or wish of your own then here is a help that you can take if it’s your friends anniversary then here are the best happy anniversary wishes for a friend. Best wedding anniversary wishes will surely make their day. Happy Wedding Anniversary Wishes Messages and text are small things which give you long time happiness. Here are also some best happy wedding anniversary images with wishes. Happy anniversary wishes to a friend is the best thing you can give him or her. If you are looking for weddings anniversary wishes for some lovely and close to your heart couples then you should definitely look here. We will also provide happy anniversary wishes to husband to wife or wife to husband or my love in our next post. Some best happy wedding anniversary wishes for your mom and dad, for your boss, for your colleagues and of course for your best friend’s wedding anniversary. We have also provided some awesome wedding anniversary quotes that you can send to your friends or relatives on their happy anniversary.  

Only a grin and the rain is gone Can barely trust it, better believe it. There's a blessed messenger remaining beside me. Going after my heart Just a grin and it is extremely unlikely back.Can scarcely trust it, no doubt But there's a heavenly attendant calling me. Going after my heart I realize that I'll be alright at this point. This time, it's genuine I lay my adoration on you It's all I wanna do Every time I inhale I feel fresh out of the box new You open up my heart Show me all your affection and walk directly through As I lay my adoration on you. Best Essays Writing

—Owen Garner

Pursuing my heart Just a smile and it is to a great degree far-fetched back.Can hardly believe it, presumably But there's a radiant chaperon calling me. Pursuing my heart I understand that I'll be okay now. Al Pacino Tony Montana Scarface Jacket This time, it's bona fide I lay my veneration on you It's all I wanna do Every time I breathe in I learn about new of the case new You open up my heart Show me all your friendship and walk specifically through As I lay my love on you.

—Owen Potts

There are many interesting information here. http://home-buyer.co.uk

Thank you very much.

 

Abdullahpc

—Anonymous

I am so happy to read this. This is the kind of manual that needs to be given and not the random misinformation that's at the other blogs.  

  I found a considerable measure of interesting data here.  A decent post, extremely grateful and cheerful that you will compose numerous more posts like this one.  Keep it up for more valuable sharing. Well thank u so much..  Unity Patch  

Keep it up good work andfor more valuable sharing. Well thank u so much,

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p>
  • HTML tags will be transformed to conform to HTML standards.

More information about formatting options