Wireless Power Transfer to Ground Sensors Using a UAV (Quadrotor)

Quadrotor Wirelessly Powering a Sensor

We were scanning through the upcoming ICRA2012 program and noticed an interesting paper titled, "Resonant Wireless Power Transfer to Ground Sensors from a UAV."    This certainly piqued our interest -- especially for Travis, who happens to work with wirelessly-powered sensors at his day job.  Come to find out...  the article is by Dr. Carrick Detweiler, PI of the NIMBUS Lab at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (our undergrad alma mater!).  Furthermore, he just provided a preprint of the paper (PDF) and a video on his website.  Score!  Their quadrotor delivers power via magnetic resonance (ie. WiTricity-style) to a load on the ground.  This same type of technology is being actively researched for lots of applications, including: consumer electronics, transportation (eg. electric vehicle recharging), and remote sensing (this application).  Adding it to a UAV adds a bit of flexibility to the system.   Anyway, be sure to check out the video below... and we'll also give a brief overview of a few different wireless power + robotics projects over the ages.

 

Wireless Power Transfer to Ground Sensors Using a UAV (Quadrotor)

 

The paper is titled, "Resonant Wireless Power Transfer to Ground Sensors from a UAV" (PDF) by Brent Griffin and Dr. Carrick Detweiler.  Here's the video provided on Carrick's website:

Wireless Power UAV  Wireless Power UAV

 

Magnetic resonance can be a good method for wireless power transfer at medium distances (ie. a meter or so).  Owing to the resonant fields, it is more efficient that inductive coupling, which would require the UAV to be in close proximity to the load (a few centimeters) to get good mutual coupling.  Furthermore, the magnetic fields are less susceptible to occlusions or material composition compared to microwave (electromagnetic) or laser-based wireless power transfer.  

However, being at least partially familiar with the underlying technology, we know that alignment and (dynamic) frequency tuning are absolutely critical for efficient power transfer using magnetic resonance.  Presumably, the quadrotor itself could supply the necessary flexibility in the system to help align the coils -- heck, we've all seen quadrotors perform impressive feats of acrobatics.  So kudos to Carrick and Brent for their insights!

In case you were wondering... wireless power and robotics actually have a long​ history.  We thought we'd highlight a few projects for the curious...

 

 

Microwave Wireless Power Transfer (Rectenna-Based)

 

In Dr. Detweiler's case, the wireless power transfer is going from drone-to-ground.  The reverse direction, from ground-to-drone, has a long​ history going back to the 1960's.   In "The History of Power Transmission by Radio Waves" (PDF), we see microwave electromagnetic radiation and rectifying antennas (rectennas) being used for wireless power transfer:

Wireless Power UAV   Wireless Power UAV

Left: The special "string" rectenna made for the first microwave-powered helicopter in 1964.  The array area of four square feet contained 4480 IN82G point-contact diodes.  Maximum DC power was 270 Watts.

Right: Microwave-powered helicopter in flight 60 ft above a transmitting antenna.  The helicopter was demonstrated to media in October 1964.  A 10-hour sustained flight was achieved in November of that same year.

 

More recently (1992), projects like MILAX used microwave rectenna-based power transfer systems to supply power to a airplane (UAV) that stayed aloft above a moving vehicle!  (photo source)

Wireless Power UAV  Wireless Power UAV

 

Now... robot-to-sensor power transfer isn't exactly new either.  In fact, it's the basic operating principle behind many RFID technologies (eg. passive long-range RFID) that use electromagnetic radiation to power a small piece of silicon (typically for just identification, but many new variants are coming bundled with sensors).  Hizook's own, Travis Deyle, did his PhD thesis on this topic:  "Ultra High Frequency (UHF) Radio-Frequency Identification (RFID) for Robot Perception and Mobile Manipulation."  We covered its appearance on CNN, where the PR2 holds the power transmit antennas and powers the remote "sensors" (long-range RFID tags) from several meters away.  This could easily be extended to a UAV too... [ Can't divulge too much more since it's an active area of Travis' research.  We promise to give a more in-depth analysis later!  ;-) ]

 

 

Non-Resonant Wireless Power Transfer to a Swarm of Robots 

 

We already briefly mentioned inductive power transfer... But this topic is special for Hizook. Wirelessly powered robot swarms were the subject of our very first Hizook post.  It was also one of Travis' earliest publications, presented back at ICRA 2008 in a paper titled, "Surface Based Wireless Power Transmission and Bidrectional Communication for Autonomous Robot Swarms"  (PDF and presentation slides). 

Wirelessly Powered Robot Swarm  Wirelessly Powered Robot Swarm  Wirelessly Powered Robot Swarm

Wirelessly Powered Robot Swarm  Wirelessly Powered Robot Swarm

This form of wireless power transfer will be immediately familiar to anyone who uses access control badges (eg. in their ID cards or for subway access).  This is basically a low-frequency (125kHz) or high-frequency (13.56 MHz) RFID system where the coil under the table is the reader and the robots are the tags!

In this case... the non-resonant power transfer is actually preferable.  One oft-omitted fact about resonant power transfer is that the presence of three (or more) coils will naturally de-tune the system.  You can try to solve this problems in a few ways: sense the multiple peaks in the system response and transmit at those frequencies only, or try to do time-division multiplexing.  Either way, it would add a lot of system complexity to a swarm application and would probably make inductive coupling preferable!  

Regardless... Travis was little surprised (disappointed?) that Brent and Carrick didn't cite this work.  He did a very similar analysis of the power availability above our coil(s), and it would have proved a very apt comparison.  ;-)

 

 

Optical Wireless Power Transfer (Lasers!)

 

No discussion of wireless power transfer is complete without discussing lasers!  Between 2005 and 2009 (excluding 2008), NASA held a competition to beam power to a robot on a tether as part of the "Centennial Challenges program" to build a space elevator!  In 2009, LaserMotive won the challenge (and $900,000) when their robot made it 900m up the tether.  Today, LaserMotive is actively working to build wirelessly powered UAVs using similar light beaming techniques.  Of course, there are other laser-powered airplanes too.

UAV powered by light  UAV powered by light  UAV powered by light

 

 

 

Anyway... Kudos to the folks at the NIMBUS Lab for showing us another new trick!  Oh, and did we mention that University of Nebraska-Lincoln is our undergrad alma mater?  Go Big RED!  ;-)

This article was jointly written by Travis Deyle and Robert Powers.

 

Comments

A friend pointed me to the website of Jonathan How (MIT Professor) that mentions "Battery change / recharge station to enable persistent autonomous quadrotor flight."  However, searching through his webpage (and the linked page) doesn't seem to have any additional information... bummer.

Wirelessly Powered UAV

—Travis Deyle

Hello,

This is a very interesting article like the others ;-). Was taking a glance through Travis slides on the non-resonant power transfer. Looks very interesting, I will need to sit down and read the accompanying paper. Although I am curious what the maximum size of the operating theatre can be for this system before there is a loss in efficiency?

Would also be curious to know what kind of heat generation this system could have on the operating surface too? For our micro-robots we are using a power floor in direct contact which has its own advantages and disadvantages but this type of technology was never taken too far as it was suspected it could affect our application. Definitely something I will need to follow up further on.

Cheers,

—Will C

@Will,

Keeping all other variables constant, the flux density will decrease with larger surface area.  Conceptually, this results in less magnetic flux flowing through the robot's receiver coils -- ie. it decreases the mutual coupling between the transmit (primary) and the receiving (secondary) coils.  By making the surface much bigger than the robot, you're essentially saying "we're OK with a low mutual coupling, because we want to drive multiple robots simultaneously."  For our system, each added robot consumed something like 300 mW out of a total of 12 W (transmitted).  So... with four robots, the system efficiency was really low (~10% IIRC), but would increase with more robots.  The rest of the power is wasted.

If you go the other direction and shrink the coils, then there is more flux per robot coil, so the mutual coupling increases.  In the limit, if you shrink the coils to a small, equal size (and add a ferromagnetic core), you can get super-high efficiencies: eg. 90%, like a wireless toothbrush.  But then you can't have lots of robots operating simultaneously -- which is no fun.  So really... it's a big application tradeoff. 

I hope that helps.  ;-)

—Travis Deyle

Hi

Just read the article on wireless power transfere, which I found very interesting. I am now wondering which means of transfere would be best for the solar space generator satelites to send power to a terra rectenna? It seems to be a question of which transfere solution has the least loss at conversion, transportation and inversion, plus the efficency of the system when considering cost verses output. Do you believe these are the only major considerations or do you believe there to be others? Am I right in believing that its down to Microwave or LASER as the only viable options in this field?

Any reply would be greatly appreciated as there is alot of information on the subject and two subject matter experts, such as yourselves, could greatly help me narrow my research field.

Rgds

Tex        

—Tex

Just saw another wirelessly-powered quadcopter over on Hacked Gadgets:

This video demonstrates the possible applications of wireless power transfer via resonant inductive coupling. The battery of the quadrotor is replaced with a coil which receives power from another coil on the table. The resonant frequency is 800kHz, the primary coil driver is a Class E DC/AC inverter capable of delivering up to 20 W of power.

—Travis Deyle

I was discussing wirelessly-powered robots with a friend who was interested in powering small drones. I said, "It wouldn't surprise me if someone has already done resonant power transfer to drones." Turns out that I was correct. I found a paper on this very subject:

"Wireless Power Feeding with Strongly Coupled Magnetic Resonance for a Flying Object" by Masayoshi Koizumi, Kimiya Komurasaki, Yoshihiro Mizuno, and Yoshihiro Arakawa from back in 2011.

Resonant Wireless Power Transfer to Drone

Resonant Wireless Power Transfer to Drone

 

—Travis Deyle

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <p>
  • HTML tags will be transformed to conform to HTML standards.

More information about formatting options